Home Page tree image Featured Member Directory About SCBWI
RA Ramblings NOSCBWI Info Events and Meetings Articles Good News Area Critique Groups bookbasket Contact Links Search FAQ Tidbits FAQ Tidbits

Conference ~ 2008
General Info| How to Prepare Your Work for Critique | Tips for Having a Satisfactory Critique | Faculty | Conference Schedule| Registration Form (PDF) | (Word)

 

Tips for Having a Satisfactory Critique

 

  • Be on time for your critique and when your time is up, be considerate and leave promptly so the next person's critique can start on time, too.
  • Keep your expectations realistic. Chances are you will not be offered a contract on the spot. However you may receive suggestions to strengthen your manuscript/illustrations or perhaps receive an invitation to submit more work. And you can make a good impression, leaving the agent/editor with the thought that you are professional and someone he/she would like to work with.
  • Listen more than you talk.
  • Don't be afraid to ask for clarification of the critiquer's comments, if needed.
  • For authors, be prepared to sum up your book in a pithy 2-3 sentences, similar to blurbs on book jackets. For illustrators, be prepared to discuss your "style."
  • Do ask questions such as, "What do you see as my strengths? What do you see as my weaknesses?"
  • Be polite. Thank the editor/agent for your critique, and perhaps even follow up with a hand-written thank you note after the conference.
  • Be prepared to ask questions which will help you understand what type of work your critiquer likes, is looking for, and what you can do to meet his/her standards.
  • Don't forget to network with fellow authors and illustrators (you might want to bring business cards to make it easy to exchange contact information).